Edinburgh Tournament - Silver Jubilee Salver
Originally this event was for handicaps 3 and over, and was a handicap event. The Silver Jubilee Salver was donated by members of Edinburgh CC in 1975 (the 25th anniversary of the Club’s formation) – prior to that there had been no permanent trophy.
From 1977 it was Level Singles handicap 3 and over (unless otherwise stated).
From 1987, on the introduction of the Ian H. Wright Trophy for advanced play for handicaps 4 and over, this trophy was for the Level Singles event for handicaps 8 and over.
From 1988, it reverted to handicap play for handicaps 8 and over.
Roll of honour:
|
1969 |
W.M. Spalding (4) |
|
1972 |
Miss A.M. Murray (8) |
|
1973 |
Mrs C.A. Rowe (7) |
|
1974 |
P. Crawford (4½) |
|
1975 |
R. ap W. Williams (3½) |
|
1976 |
J.E. Rowe (7) |
|
1977 |
S.R.C. Malin (4) |
|
1978 |
G.L. Anderson (5) |
|
1979 |
M.P.W. Smith (5½) |
|
1980 |
J.A. Lomax (7) |
|
1981 |
P.H.B. Boddington (7) |
|
1982 |
A.H.M. Adam (7) |
|
1983 |
P.W. Thompson (5½) |
|
1984 |
G. Anderson (7½) |
|
1985 |
A.G.M. Hunter (5½) |
|
1986 |
D.S. Warhurst (6½) |
|
1987 |
F. Mann (8) |
|
1988 |
V. George (10) |
|
1989 |
G.A. Coull (9) |
|
1990 |
B.G. Townsend (13) |
|
1991 |
C.M. Townsend (10) |
|
1992 |
S. McKendrick (14) |
|
1993 |
R. Goudie (12) |
|
1994 |
B. Medley (10) |
|
1995 |
P. Smith (12) |
|
1996 |
M.P.W. Smith (12) |
|
1997 |
J. Walker (9) |
|
1998 |
F.R. McInnes (10) |
|
1999 |
P.R. Smith (12) |
|
2000 |
J.D. Seddon (10) |
|
2001 |
J.D. Seddon (9) |
|
2002 |
R. Goudie (11) |
|
2003 |
R.A. Hawke (16) |
|
2004 |
M.A. Stephenson (14) |
|
2005 |
R. Goudie |
|
2006 |
J.M. Clark |
|
2007 |
J.M. Clark |
|
2008 |
R. Goudie |
|
2009 |
J.P. Edgar |
|
2010 |
J.P. Edgar |
|
2011 |
J. Walker |
|
2012 |
not contested |
Results:
1969: W.M. Spalding (4, 4 wins) beat M.A. Brougham +16, J.C. McCulloch +11, Cmdr. J.E. Rowe +6, K.H. Paterson +19
Cmdr. J.E. Rowe (7, 3 wins) beat M.A. Brougham +24, J.C. McCulloch +11, K.H. Paterson +1T
K.H. Paterson (3½, 2 wins) beat M.A. Brougham +19, J.C. McCulloch +13
M.A. Brougham (7, 1 win) beat J.C. McCulloch +2T
J.C. McCulloch (6, 0 wins)
1972: Final:
Miss A.M. Murray (8) beat L. Middleton (6½) +4
1973: Round 1:
J.E. Rowe (5) beat R.O. Calder (4) +6
Miss A.M. Murray (6) beat J. Shearer (8) +16
Round 2:
J.E. Rowe beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson (8) +16
J.C. McCulloch (7) beat N. McKinnon (7) +7
Mrs C.A. Rowe (7) beat C.J. Tait (7) +17
Miss A.M. Murray beat J. White (8) +5
Round 3:
J.E. Rowe beat J.C. McCulloch +8
Mrs C.A. Rowe beat Miss A.M. Murray +9
Final:
Mrs C.A. Rowe beat J.E. Rowe +9
Consolation Event:
Final:
Mrs V.M. Macpherson beat J. White +9
1974:
Draw: Round 1:
J. White (7) beat P. Crawford (4.5) +7
R. Calder (6) beat D. Willetts (6.5) +14
Semi-finals:
J. White beat A. Saalfeld (4) +2
R. Calder beat Mrs S. Willetts (9) +19
Final:
R. Calder beat J. White +4
Process: Round 1:
A. Saalfeld beat R. Calder +12
P. Crawford beat Mrs S. Willetts +12
Semi-finals:
A. Saalfeld beat J. White +12
P. Crawford beat D. Willetts +20
Final:
P. Crawford beat A. Saalfeld +5
Final: P. Crawford beat R. Calder +11
1975: Round 1:
Mrs C.A. Rowe (7) beat J.G. White (5) +2
J.E. Rowe (8) beat C.J. Tait (9) +2
Round 2:
Mrs V.M. Macpherson (8) beat R. Forth (9) +13
Mrs C.A. Rowe beat D. Anderson (11) +2
R. Williams (3½) beat J.E. Rowe +7
A.D. Lamont (14) beat J. Ferguson (12) +15
Semi-finals:
Mrs Rowe beat Mrs Macpherson +3
Rod Williams beat Donald Lamont +10
Final:
Rod Williams beat Carol Rowe +15
1976: Main Event:
Round 1:
J.C. Shearer (8) beat P.T. Barnes (5) +2T
Mrs S. Willetts (8) beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson (7) +2T
Round 2:
D.C. Willetts (6) beat A.D. Lamont (9) +9
J.C. Shearer beat Mrs C.A. Rowe (6½) +2T
Mrs S. Willetts beat R.ap W. Williams (3) +2T
J.E. Rowe (7) beat A. Gordon (6½) +18
Semi-finals:
D.C. Willetts beat J.C. Shearer +3
J.E. Rowe beat Mrs S. Willetts +1
Final:
J.E. Rowe beat D.C. Willetts +7T
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
Mrs C.A. Rowe beat P.J. Barnes +11
R. Williams beat Mrs V. Macpherson +3T
Round 2:
Mrs Rowe beat A.D. Lamont +7
R. Williams beat A. Gordon +13
Final:
Rod Williams beat Carol Rowe +4T
1977: From 1977 this event is Level Singles
Main Event:
Round 1:
Mrs V.M. Macpherson beat E. Mackenzie-Bowie +20
J.E. Rowe beat C.J. Tait +23
S. Malin beat J.C. Shearer +4
Round 2:
Mrs C.A. Rowe w/o (Mrs Macpherson scr)
S. Malin beat J.E. Rowe +12
Final:
S.Malin beat Mrs C.A. Rowe +11
Consolation Event:
E. Mackenzie-Bowie beat C.J. Tait +4T
Final:
J.C. Shearer beat E. Mackenzie-Bowie +12
1978:
Draw: Round 1:
Mrs M. Lauder beat J.E. Rowe +11
Mrs V.M. Macpherson w/o G.L. Anderson
Round 2:
L. Middleton beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson +4
Mrs M. Lauder beat C.J. Tait +8
Final:
Mrs M. Lauder beat L. Middleton +9
Process: Round 1:
L. Middleton beat C.J. Tait +10
G.L. Anderson beat J.E. Rowe +17
Round 2:
G.L. Anderson beat L. Middleton +23
Mrs M. Lauder beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson +11
Final:
G.L. Anderson beat Mrs M. Lauder +13
Final: G.L. (Gavin) Anderson beat Mrs Margaret Lauder +8
1979:
|
|
MPWS |
ML |
VM |
RF |
Wins |
|
Malcolm Smith |
|
+5, +3, -8 |
+2, -8 |
+6, +18 |
5 |
|
Margaret Lauder |
-5, -3 |
|
+6, -3T |
+10, +22 |
3 |
|
Vera Macpherson |
-2, +8 |
-6, +3T |
|
+8 |
2 |
|
Reg Forth |
-6, -18 |
-10, -22 |
-8 |
|
0 |
1980: Handicap 6 and over
Main Event:
Round 1:
R. Forth beat A.G.M. Hunter +8T
G.C. Roy beat A.D. Lamont +6T
J. Lomax beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson +2T
Round 2:
R. Forth beat G.C. Roy +1T
J. Lomax beat C.J. Tait +4T
Final:
J. Lomax beat R. Forth +22
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
A.G.M. Hunter beat A.D. Lamont +3T
C.J. Tait beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson +14
Final:
A.G.M. Hunter beat C.J. Tait +1T
1981: Handicap 6½ and over
Main Event:
Round 1:
P. Boddington beat Mrs V.M. Macpherson +6
A.G.M. Hunter beat J. Lomax +9T
P.W. Thompson beat C.J. Tait +16
Round 2:
P. Boddington beat A.G.M. Hunter +9T
A.D. Lamont beat P.W. Thompson +14
Final:
P. Boddington beat A.D. Lamont +13T
Consolation Event:
Final:
J. Lomax beat C.J. Tait +14
1982:
Draw: Round 1:
Alasdair Adam beat Peter Thompson +2T
Alastair Hunter beat George Anderson +7T
Round 2:
Alasdair Adam beat John McCulloch +2T
Alastair Hunter beat Donald Lamont +13
Final:
Alasdair Adam beat Alastair Hunter +7
Process: Round 1:
Alastair Hunter beat John McCulloch +19
Alasdair Adam beat Donald Lamont +6T
Round 2:
Alastair Hunter beat Peter Thompson +3
Alasdair Adam beat George Anderson +21
Final:
Alasdair Adam beat Alastair Hunter +5
Final: Alasdair Adam won both Draw and Process
Alastair Hunter was runner-up in both Draw and Process
1983: No details found in Bulletin 27 (April 1984)
Final:
Peter Thompson beat Allan Ramsay
‘Y’ final:
Caroline Hay beat James Marshal
1984: No records have been found
Winner:
George Anderson
1985: Main Event:
Round 1:
G. Anderson beat C.M. van Griethuysen +1T
D. Jesson-Dibley beat M.P.W. Smith +3
A.M. Ramsay beat D. Warhurst +23
A.G.M. Hunter beat R. Hissett +7
Round 2:
G.Anderson beat D. Jesson-Dibley +19
A.G.M. Hunter beat A.M. Ramsay +3
Final:
A.G.M. Hunter beat G. Anderson +4T
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
C.M. van Griethuysen beat M.P.W. Smith +19
D. Warhurst beat R. Hissett +21
Final:
C.M. van Griethuysen beat D. Warhurst +5T
1986: Main Event:
Round 1:
P.G. Simpson beat R. Hissett +21
D.R. Appleton beat W.G. Masterton +4
A.M. Ramsay beat D.C. Willetts +9
Round 2:
C.M. van Griethuysen beat R. Weaver +10
P.G. Simpson beat D.R. Appleton +3
A.M. Ramsay w/o A.G.M. Hunter
D.S. Warhurst beat C.A. Rowe +19
Round 3:
C.M. van Griethuysen beat P.G. Simpson +15
D.S. Warhurst beat A.M. Ramsay +3
Final:
D.S. Warhurst beat C.M. van Griethuysen +5
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
W.G. Masterton beat R. Hissett +13
Round 2:
R. Weaver beat W.G. Masterton +2
C.A. Rowe beat D.C. Willetts +9
Final:
R. Weaver beat C.A. Rowe +14
1987: Main Event:
Round 1:
Phillip Simpson beat Bill Masterton +6 (this result may be incorrectly recorded, as Bill Masterton is recorded as losing in Round 2 and Phillip Simpson is recorded as scratched from the Consolation Event)
Fred Mann beat Charles Waterfield +20
Mary Fotheringham beat Roger Hissett +13T
Round 2:
Drew Nisbet beat Reg Forth +1T
Fred Mann beat Bill Masterton +11T
Carol Rowe beat Mary Fotheringham +1T
Donald Lamont beat Colin McArthur +8
Round 3:
Fred Mann beat Drew Nisbet +18
Donald Lamont beat Carol Rowe +6T
Final:
Fred Mann beat Donald Lamont +12
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
Colin McArthur beat Reg Forth +12T
Round 2:
Colin McArthur w/o Phillip Simpson
Charles Waterfield beat Roger Hissett +5T
Final:
Charles Waterfield beat Colin McArthur +22
1988: Handicap Singles, 8 bisques and over
Final:
Vincent George (11) beat Niall Smith (9) +4
Consolation Event:
Final:
John Beech (8) beat Donald Lamont (8) +3T
1989: Main Event:
Round 1:
G. Coull beat A. Quin +1T
Round 2:
G. Coull beat R. Ottley +15
D. Lamont beat B.R.P. Murdoch +14
R. Forth beat T. Quin +5T
M. Fotheringham beat V. George +3T
Semi-finals:
G. Coull beat D. Lamont +6
M. Fotheringham beat R. Forth +6T
Final:
G. Coull beat M. Fotheringham +2T
Consolation Event:
Round 1:
R. Ottley beat A. Quin +4
Semi-finals:
B.R.P. Murdoch beat R. Ottley +7T
T. Quin beat V. George +4T
Final:
T. Quin beat B.R.P. Murdoch +7T
1990: Block A:
|
|
BT |
BF |
DL |
CM |
Wins |
Points |
|
Basil Townsend |
|
+12T |
+7T |
+17 |
3 |
+36 |
|
Bob Fewtrell |
-12T |
|
+15 |
+16T |
2 |
+19 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-7T |
-15 |
|
+6T |
1 |
-16 |
|
Campbell Morrison |
-17 |
-16T |
-6T |
|
0 |
-39 |
Block B:
|
|
TO |
RF |
BM |
AR |
Wins |
Points |
|
Trevor Owen |
|
+9T |
+19 |
+6 |
3 |
+34 |
|
Reg Forth |
-9T |
|
+7T |
+5T |
2 |
+3 |
|
Brian Murdoch |
-19 |
-7T |
|
+9T |
1 |
-17 |
|
Anne Rutter |
-6 |
-5T |
-9T |
|
0 |
-20 |
Semi-finals: Basil Townsend beat Reg Forth +7
Bob Fewtrell beat Trevor Owen +12
Final: Basil Townsend beat Bob Fewtrell +1T
1991: No detailed results have been found
Advanced with bisques
Winner:
Charlotte Townsend 6 wins/6
Runner-up:
Brian Murdoch 5/6
1992: Block A:
|
|
SMcK |
BM |
CR |
RF |
Wins |
Points |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
|
+3T |
+6 |
+1T |
3 |
+10 |
|
Brian Murdoch |
-3T |
|
+16 |
+12 |
2 |
+25 |
|
Carol Rowe |
-6 |
-16 |
|
+2T |
1 |
-20 |
|
Reg Forth |
-1T |
-12 |
-2T |
|
0 |
-15 |
Block B:
|
|
PS |
CR |
JR |
DL |
Wins |
Points |
|
Peter Smith |
|
+12 |
+21 |
+10 |
3 |
+43 |
|
Chris Robertson |
-12 |
|
+4 |
+19 |
2 |
+11 |
|
Jimmy Rowe |
-21 |
-4 |
|
+1T |
1 |
-24 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-10 |
-19 |
-1T |
|
0 |
-30 |
Final: Stuart McKendrick beat Peter Smith +2T
1993: Block A:
|
|
RG |
SMcK |
NG |
JR |
Wins |
Points |
|
Ruth Goudie |
|
+9 |
+13 |
+11 |
3 |
+33 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-9 |
|
+5 |
+11 |
2 |
+7 |
|
Nigel Gardner |
-13 |
-5 |
|
+12 |
1 |
-6 |
|
Jimmy Rowe |
-11 |
-11 |
-12 |
|
0 |
-34 |
Block B:
|
|
PS |
DL |
CR |
AR |
Wins |
Points |
|
Peter Smith |
|
+1T |
+23 |
+19 |
3 |
+43 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-1T |
|
-12 |
+10 |
1 |
-3 |
|
Carol Rowe |
-23 |
+12 |
|
- |
1 |
-11 |
|
Allan Ramsay |
-19 |
-10 |
- |
|
0 |
-29 |
Final: Ruth Goudie beat Peter Smith +1T
1994: Block A:
|
|
BM |
NG |
PS |
DL |
CR |
Wins |
Points |
|
Brian Medley |
|
+7 |
+9T |
+2T |
+8 |
4 |
+26 |
|
Nigel Gardner |
-7 |
|
+9T |
+19 |
+1 |
3 |
+22 |
|
Peter Smith |
-9T |
-9T |
|
+5T |
+6T |
2 |
-7 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-2T |
-19 |
-5T |
|
+11 |
1 |
-15 |
|
Chris Robertson |
-8 |
-1 |
-6T |
-11 |
|
0 |
-26 |
Block B:
|
|
TB |
SMc |
RG |
MS |
DJ |
Wins |
Points |
|
Tony Brightman |
|
+16 |
+19 |
+23 |
+5 |
4 |
+63 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-16 |
|
- |
+6 |
+1T |
2 |
-9 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
-19 |
- |
|
+5 |
+3T |
2 |
-11 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-23 |
-6 |
-5 |
|
+5 |
1 |
-29 |
|
Doris James |
-5 |
-1T |
-3T |
-5 |
|
0 |
-14 |
Final: Brian Medley beat Tony Brightman +4T
1995:
|
|
PS |
SMc |
RG |
CR |
JK |
DL |
MS |
Wins |
Points |
|
Peter Smith |
|
+15 |
-10T |
+1T |
+10 |
+3T |
+8T |
5 |
+27 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-15 |
|
+17 |
+3 |
+9 |
-1T |
+4 |
4 |
+17 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
+10T |
-17 |
|
+2T |
-11 |
+8T |
+1T |
4 |
-7 |
|
Chris Robertson |
-1T |
-3 |
-2T |
|
+1T |
+9T |
-7 |
2 |
-3 |
|
Jolyon Kay |
-10 |
-9 |
+11 |
-1T |
|
-5T |
+4T |
2 |
-10 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-3T |
+1T |
-8T |
-9T |
+5T |
|
- |
2 |
-14 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-8T |
-4 |
-1T |
+7 |
-4T |
- |
|
1 |
-10 |
1996: Block A:
|
|
MS |
PS |
SM |
RG |
Wins |
Points |
|
Malcolm Smith |
|
+5T |
+2T |
+19 |
3 |
+26 |
|
Peter Smith |
-5T |
|
+5 |
+12 |
2 |
+12 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-2T |
-5 |
|
+15 |
1 |
+8 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
-19 |
-12 |
-15 |
|
0 |
-46 |
Block B:
|
|
BR |
TF |
DL |
Wins |
|
Brian Rees |
|
+9, +7T |
+12 |
3 |
|
Tony Foster |
-9, -7T |
|
+8 |
1 |
|
Donald Lamont |
-12 |
-8 |
|
0 |
Final: Malcolm Smith beat Brian Rees +2
1997:
|
|
JW |
MS |
CR |
JK |
PM |
EO |
Wins |
Points |
|
Jamieson Walker |
|
+7 |
+1T |
+6T |
+6 |
+8T |
5 |
+28 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-7 |
|
+1T |
+16 |
+3T |
+2T |
4 |
+15 |
|
Chris Robertson |
-1T |
-1T |
|
+19 |
+5 |
+7 |
3 |
+29 |
|
Jolyon Kay |
-6T |
-16 |
-19 |
|
+2 |
+14 |
2 |
-25 |
|
Patrick McCann |
-6 |
-3T |
-5 |
-2 |
|
+4 |
1 |
-12 |
|
Esme Owen |
-8T |
-2T |
-7 |
-14 |
-4 |
|
0 |
-35 |
1998: Block A:
|
|
FM |
MS |
PS |
EO |
Wins |
Points |
|
Fergus McInnes |
|
-1 |
+11 |
+4T |
2 |
+14 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
+1 |
|
+1T |
-1T |
2 |
+1 |
|
Peter Smith |
-11 |
-1T |
|
+7 |
1 |
-5 |
|
Esme Owen |
-4T |
+1T |
-7 |
|
1 |
-10 |
Block B:
|
|
JK |
JW |
FM |
Wins |
Points |
|
Jolyon Kay |
|
+4, +8 |
+21, -3T |
3 |
+30 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-4, -8 |
|
+19, +5T |
2 |
+12 |
|
Fred Mann |
-21, +3T |
-19, -5T |
|
1 |
-42 |
Final: Fergus McInnes beat Jolyon Kay +2T
1999: Block A
|
|
FRM |
JW |
RG |
EMO |
Wins |
Points |
|
F.R. McInnes |
— |
+6 |
+20 |
+7T |
3 |
+33 |
|
J. Walker |
-6 |
— |
+15 |
+8T |
2 |
+17 |
|
R. Goudie |
-20 |
-15 |
— |
+7T |
1 |
-28 |
|
E.M. Owen |
-7T |
-8T |
-7T |
— |
0 |
-22 |
Block B
|
|
PRS |
FM |
PJK |
MPWS |
Wins |
Points |
|
P.R. Smith |
— |
+13T |
+8T |
+13 |
3 |
+34 |
|
F. Mann |
-13T |
— |
+10 |
+12 |
2 |
+9 |
|
P.J. Kirby |
-8T |
-10 |
— |
+11 |
1 |
-7 |
|
M.P.W. Smith |
-13 |
-12 |
-11 |
— |
0 |
-36 |
Final: Peter Smith beat Fergus McInnes +1T
2000:
|
|
JDS |
PRS |
RG |
PLW |
JP |
IHW |
Wins |
Points |
|
J.D. Seddon |
— |
+6 |
+5T |
+11 |
+19 |
+21 |
5 |
+62 |
|
P.R. Smith |
-6 |
— |
+5 |
+4T |
+14 |
+9 |
4 |
+26 |
|
R. Goudie |
-5T |
-5 |
— |
+7 |
+16 |
+4T |
3 |
+17 |
|
P.L. Webb |
-11 |
-4T |
-7 |
— |
+17 |
+1 |
2 |
-4 |
|
J. Penny |
-19 |
-14 |
-16 |
-17 |
— |
+7T |
1 |
-59 |
|
I.H. Wright |
-21 |
-9 |
-4T |
-1 |
-7T |
— |
0 |
-42 |
2001:
|
|
JLT |
JDS |
IHW |
MPWS |
RG |
EMO |
Wins |
|
Jonathan Toye |
|
-6 |
+16 |
+11 |
+4 |
+15 |
4 |
|
John Seddon |
+6 |
|
+13 |
-8 |
+10 |
+13 |
4 |
|
Ian Wright |
-16 |
-13 |
|
+9 |
+6 |
+18 |
3 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-11 |
+8 |
-9 |
|
+2T |
+10 |
3 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
-4 |
-10 |
-6 |
-2T |
|
+4T |
1 |
|
Esme Owen |
-15 |
-13 |
-18 |
-10 |
-4T |
|
0 |
Final: John Seddon beat Jonathan Toye +20
2002:
|
|
RG |
JAP |
IHW |
AAW |
FM |
Wins |
|
Ruth Goudie |
|
+3T |
+2T |
-2T |
+8 |
3 |
|
Jim Penny |
-3T |
|
+7 |
-5T |
+10 |
2 |
|
Ian Wright |
-2T |
-7 |
|
+5T |
+4 |
2 |
|
Alan Wilson |
+2T |
+5T |
-5T |
|
-13 |
2 |
|
Fred Mann |
-8 |
-10 |
-4 |
+13 |
|
1 |
2003:
|
|
RAH |
MMB |
RGL |
RG |
Wins |
|
Allan Hawke |
|
-13T, +22 |
-2, +8T |
+16, +20 |
4 |
|
Mary Barnes |
+13T, -22 |
|
+7T, +19 |
+18, -1T |
4 |
|
Robert Lay |
+2, -8T |
-7T, -19 |
|
-10, +2T |
2 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
-16, -20 |
-18, +1T |
+10, -2T |
|
2 |
Final (14-point): Allan Hawke beat Mary Barnes +1T
2004:
|
|
RAH |
MSE |
MAS |
RG |
Wins |
|
Allan Hawke |
|
+10 |
-3T |
+12 |
2 |
|
Mark Elliot |
-10 |
|
+10T |
+1T |
2 |
|
Martin Stephenson |
+3T |
-10T |
|
+4T |
2 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
-12 |
-1T |
-4T |
|
0 |
Play-offs: Martin Stephenson beat Mark Elliot +11T (semi); Allan Hawke +3T (final)
2005:
|
|
RG |
IHW |
JL |
RGL |
Wins |
|
Ruth Goudie |
|
+7 |
+9 |
+15 |
3 |
|
Ian Wright |
-7 |
|
+12 |
+13 |
2 |
|
Joe Lennon |
-9 |
-12 |
|
+13 |
1 |
|
Robert Lay |
-15 |
-13 |
-13 |
|
0 |
2006:
|
|
JL |
JMC |
GH |
RMS |
RG |
Wins |
|
Joe Lennon |
|
+10 |
+4T |
-5T |
(+12) |
2 |
|
John Clark |
-10 |
|
+4T |
+3 |
|
2 |
|
Graeme Holland |
-4T |
-4T |
+20 |
|
(+5T) |
1 |
|
Richard Stevens |
+5T |
-3 |
-20 |
|
|
1 |
|
Ruth Goudie (withdrew) |
(-12) |
|
(-5T) |
|
|
(0) |
Final: John Clark beat Joe Lennon +7
2007:
|
|
JMC |
JL |
RG |
CT |
Wins |
|
J.M. Clark |
|
+1T |
+6 |
+18 |
3 |
|
J. Lennon |
-1T |
|
+23 |
+20 |
2 |
|
R. Goudie |
-6 |
-23 |
|
+1 |
1 |
|
C. Thomson |
-18 |
-20 |
-13 |
|
0 |
2008:
|
|
RG |
DR |
JL |
JW |
IHW |
Wins |
|
R.Goudie |
|
+7 |
+21 |
-6 |
+16 |
3 |
|
D. Reeves |
-7 |
|
-16 |
+8 |
+1T |
2 |
|
J. Lennon |
-21 |
+16 |
|
-6 |
+17 |
2 |
|
J. Walker |
+6 |
-8 |
+6 |
|
-13 |
2 |
|
I.H. Wright |
-16 |
-1T |
-17 |
+13 |
|
1 |
2009:
|
|
JPE |
JW |
SW |
JL |
Wins |
|
J.P. Edgar |
|
+25 |
+5T |
+14 |
3 |
|
J. Walker |
-25 |
|
+4T |
+8 |
2 |
|
S. Watts |
-5T |
-4T |
|
+13T |
1 |
|
J. Lennon |
-14 |
-8 |
-13T |
|
0 |
2010:
|
|
JPE |
AHMA |
RGL |
Wins |
|
J.P. Edgar |
|
+18, +13 |
+15, +19 |
4 |
|
A.H.M. Adam |
-18, -13 |
|
+3T |
1 |
|
R.G. Lay |
-15, -19 |
-3T |
|
0 |
The second game between A.H.M. Adam and R.G. Lay was not completed
2011:
|
|
JW |
JD |
HD |
ML |
Wins |
|
J. Walker |
|
+2T |
-7T |
+12 |
2 |
|
J. Duguid |
-2T |
|
+14T |
+12T |
2 |
|
H. Duguid |
+7T |
-14T |
|
-3T |
1 |
|
M. Lauder |
-12 |
-12T |
+3T |
|
1 |
Final: Jamieson Walker beat Janice Duguid +5T (20-15)
2012: not contested