Edinburgh Tournament - Ian H. Wright Trophy
The trophy was introduced in 1987, at which time the Silver Jubilee Salver had its handicap range increased to 8+ for Level Play.
(The March 1988 Bulletin number 32 marks the 1987 results as for the Silver Jubilee Salver, and does not mark any trophy for the 8+ Level Play event, and the report does not mention any trophy by name; the 1988 tournament report was in an early new-style Bulletin which did not list full tournament results, as these were intended to be included in the new-style Yearbook. Unfortunately this change in style meant that records of some results have not been found.)
Roll of honour:
|
1987 |
C.M. van Griethuysen (4½) |
|
1988 |
R.T.H. Barnes (5) |
|
1989 |
M.J. O’Connell (5) |
|
1990 |
F. Mann (4½) |
|
1991 |
C.G. Waterfield (4½) |
|
1992 |
R. Dourthe (8) |
|
1993 |
N. Hicks (6) |
|
1994 |
N. Hicks (5) |
|
1995 |
A.J. Campbell (4) |
|
1996 |
C.M. Townsend (6) |
|
1997 |
J.G. Potter |
|
1998 |
B.R. Durward |
|
1999 |
C. Van Essen |
|
2000 |
A.S. McKendrick |
|
2001 |
J. Walker |
|
2002 |
P. McDermott |
|
2003 |
F.R. McInnes |
|
2004 |
J.D. Seddon |
|
2005 |
J.D. Seddon |
|
2006 |
M.A. Stephenson |
|
2007 |
F.R. McInnes |
|
2008 |
not contested |
|
2009 |
A.A. Wilson |
|
2010 |
R.A. Hawke |
|
2011 |
R.A. Hawke |
|
2012 |
R.A. Hawke |
Results:
1987: Corla van Griethuysen (4 wins) beat Malcolm Smith +13, Fiona McCoig +6, Paul Campion +25, Alastair Hunter +13
Alastair Hunter (2 wins) beat Malcolm Smith +6, Fiona McCoig +22
Paul Campion (2 wins) beat Fiona McCoig +5, Alastair Hunter +8
Malcolm Smith (0 wins)
Fiona McCoig (0 wins)
1988: Final:
Richard Barnes beat Alastair Hunter +6
‘Y’ Final:
Fred Mann beat Phillip Simpson +17
1989:
Draw: Round 1:
Roger Hissett beat Alasdair Adam +3T
John Beech beat Malcolm Hutchinson +4
Round 2:
Malcolm O’Connell beat Carol Rowe +1T
Roger Hissett beat R. Kemp +2
John Beech beat Margaret Lauder +11
Malcolm Smith beat A. Judge +14
Semi-finals:
Malcolm O’Connell beat Roger Hissett +9
Malcolm Smith beat John Beech +6
Final:
Malcolm O’Connell beat Malcolm Smith +21
Process: Round 1:
Carol Rowe beat Malcolm Smith +11
Malcolm O’Connell beat A. Judge +17
Round 2:
Carol Rowe beat Alasdair Adam +4T
Malcolm Hutchinson beat R. Kemp +18
Malcolm O’Connell beat John Beech +19
Roger Hissett beat Margaret Lauder +6
Semi-finals:
Carol Rowe & Malcolm Hutchinson scratched
Malcolm O’Connell beat Roger Hissett +22
Final:
Malcolm O’Connell w/o
Final: No final necessary, as Malcolm O’Connell won both Draw and Process
1990:
|
|
FM |
CD |
MS |
AR |
CR |
Wins |
Points |
|
Fred Mann |
|
-4T |
+16 |
+5T |
+18 |
3 |
+35 |
|
Colin Dinwoodie |
+4T |
|
+14 |
-1T |
+1T |
3 |
+18 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-16 |
-14 |
|
+15 |
+16 |
2 |
+1 |
|
Allan Ramsay |
-5T |
+1T |
-15 |
|
+2T |
2 |
-17 |
|
Carol Rowe |
-18 |
-1T |
-16 |
-2T |
|
0 |
-37 |
1991: No block results have been found
Final:
Charles Waterfield beat Alastair Hunter +14
1992: Block A:
|
|
BD |
JB |
CT |
RP |
FM |
MS |
Wins |
Points |
|
Boris Dourthe |
|
+20 |
+18 |
+12 |
-5 |
+13 |
4 |
+58 |
|
John Beech |
-20 |
|
+11 |
+8 |
+13 |
+21 |
4 |
+33 |
|
Charlotte Townsend |
-18 |
-11 |
|
+6T |
+8 |
+9 |
3 |
-6 |
|
Ralph Pirrie |
-12 |
-8 |
-6T |
|
+7 |
+16 |
2 |
-3 |
|
Fred Mann |
+5 |
-13 |
-8 |
-7 |
|
+13 |
2 |
-10 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-13 |
-21 |
-9 |
-16 |
-13 |
|
0 |
-72 |
Block B:
|
|
RD |
RS |
GA |
AA |
IW |
AH |
Wins |
Points |
|
Rudolphe Dourthe |
|
-4 |
+10 |
+19 |
+11 |
+23 |
4 |
+59 |
|
Richard Sowerby |
+4 |
|
+3T |
-18 |
+4 |
+15 |
4 |
+8 |
|
George Anderson |
-10 |
-3T |
|
-3T |
+4T |
+23 |
2 |
+11 |
|
Alasdair Adam |
-19 |
+18 |
+3T |
|
-3 |
-1T |
2 |
-2 |
|
Ian Wright |
-11 |
-4 |
-4T |
+3 |
|
- |
1 |
-16 |
|
Alastair Hunter |
-23 |
-15 |
-23 |
+1T |
- |
|
1 |
-60 |
Final: Rudolphe Dourthe beat Boris Dourthe +21
1993: Block A:
|
|
NH |
BM |
CT |
Wins |
Points |
|
Norman Hicks |
|
+16, +14 |
-13, +21 |
3 |
+38 |
|
Brian Murdoch |
-16, -14 |
|
+23, +23 |
2 |
+16 |
|
Charlotte Townsend |
+13, -21 |
-23, -23 |
|
1 |
-54 |
Block B:
|
|
AC |
GA |
MS |
Wins |
Points |
|
Andy Campbell |
|
+9 |
+20, +15 |
3 |
+43 |
|
George Anderson |
-9 |
|
+7T, +2T |
2 |
0 |
|
Malcolm Smith |
-20, -15 |
-7T, -2T |
|
0 |
-43 |
Final: Norman Hicks beat Andy Campbell +10
1994:
|
|
NH |
DF |
AC |
FM |
CT |
GA |
BM |
Wins |
Points |
|
Norman Hicks |
|
-2 |
+2T |
+15 |
+26 |
+13T |
+17 |
5 |
+71 |
|
Dave Farmer |
+2 |
|
-1 |
+6 |
+26 |
+19 |
+18 |
5 |
+70 |
|
Andy Campbell |
-2T |
+1 |
|
+23 |
+9T |
+15 |
+2T |
5 |
+48 |
|
Fred Mann |
-15 |
-6 |
-23 |
|
-2T |
+7T |
+15 |
2 |
-24 |
|
Charlotte Townsend |
-26 |
-26 |
-9T |
+2T |
|
+1T |
-9 |
2 |
-67 |
|
George Anderson |
-13T |
-19 |
-15 |
-7T |
-1T |
|
+6T |
1 |
-49 |
|
Brian Murdoch |
-17 |
-18 |
-2T |
-15 |
+9 |
-6T |
|
1 |
-49 |
1995: Block A:
|
|
AA |
NG |
FF |
Wins |
Points |
|
Alasdair Adam |
|
+3T, +9 |
-21, +17 |
3 |
+8 |
|
Nigel Gardner |
-3T, -9 |
|
+6T, +15 |
2 |
+9 |
|
Faith Fewtrell |
+21, -17 |
-6T, -15 |
|
1 |
-17 |
Block B:
|
|
AC |
BM |
CT |
MM |
Wins |
Points |
|
Andy Campbell |
|
+4T |
+3 |
+15 |
3 |
+22 |
|
Brian Murdoch |
-4T |
|
+23 |
+5 |
2 |
+24 |
|
Charlotte Townsend |
-3 |
-23 |
|
+17 |
1 |
-9 |
|
Michael Mills |
-15 |
-5 |
-17 |
|
0 |
-37 |
Final: Andy Campbell beat Alasdair Adam +21
1996: Block A:
|
|
CT |
GA |
DG |
Wins |
Points |
|
Charlotte Townsend |
|
+8T, +8 |
+6T, -4 |
3 |
+18 |
|
George Anderson |
-8T, -8 |
|
+2, +6 |
2 |
-8 |
|
Douglas Gurney |
-6T, +4 |
-2, -6 |
|
1 |
-10 |
Block B:
|
|
BM |
DA |
PC |
FM |
Wins |
Points |
|
Brian Murdoch |
|
+7 |
+15 |
+17 |
3 |
+39 |
|
Dave Arnot |
-7 |
|
+8 |
+7T |
2 |
+8 |
|
Paul Campion |
-15 |
-8 |
|
+3 |
1 |
-20 |
|
Fred Mann |
-17 |
-7T |
-3 |
|
0 |
-27 |
Final: Charlotte Townsend beat Brian Murdoch +2
1997:
|
|
JP |
SM |
GA |
CvE |
RG |
PS |
NG |
Wins |
Points |
|
Jim Potter |
|
+8 |
+24 |
+23 |
- |
+20 |
+18 |
5 |
+93 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-8 |
|
- |
- |
+7 |
+21 |
+9T |
3 |
+29 |
|
George Anderson |
-24 |
- |
|
+15 |
+12 |
+16 |
- |
3 |
+19 |
|
Christopher Van Essen |
-23 |
- |
-15 |
|
-1T |
+5T |
+17 |
2 |
-17 |
|
Ruth Goudie |
- |
-7 |
-12 |
+1T |
|
-1T |
- |
1 |
-19 |
|
Peter Smith |
-20 |
-21 |
-16 |
-5T |
+1T |
|
- |
1 |
-61 |
|
Nigel Gardner |
-18 |
-9T |
- |
-17 |
- |
- |
|
0 |
-44 |
1998:
|
|
BD |
JP |
SM |
CVE |
NG |
DA |
Wins |
Points |
|
Brian Durward |
|
+2T |
+3 |
+26 |
+22 |
+18 |
5 |
+71 |
|
Jim Potter |
-2T |
|
+10 |
+4 |
+16 |
+1 |
4 |
+29 |
|
Stuart McKendrick |
-3 |
-10 |
|
+10 |
+13 |
+16 |
3 |
+26 |
|
Christopher Van Essen |
-26 |
-4 |
-10 |
|
+6T |
+16 |
2 |
-18 |
|
Nigel Gardner |
-22 |
-16 |
-13 |
-6T |
|
+4 |
1 |
-53 |
|
David Arnot |
-18 |
-1 |
-16 |
-16 |
-4 |
|
0 |
-55 |
1999:
|
|
CVE |
ASM |
DPA |
JGP |
GA |
NTG |
Wins |
Points |
|
C. Van Essen |
|
+1T |
+2 |
+4T |
+1T |
+1T |
5 |
+9 |
|
A.S. McKendrick |
-1T |
|
+9 |
+19 |
+7 |
+20 |
4 |
+54 |
|
D.P. Arnot |
-2 |
-9 |
|
+1T |
-3T |
+14 |
2 |
+1 |
|
J.G. Potter |
-4T |
-19 |
-1T |
|
+5 |
+4 |
2 |
-15 |
|
G. Anderson |
-1T |
-7 |
+3T |
-5 |
|
-7 |
1 |
-17 |
|
N.T. Gardner |
-1T |
-20 |
-14 |
-4 |
+7 |
|
1 |
-32 |
2000:
|
|
ASM |
CIM |
BRD |
FRM |
JW |
FM |
Wins |
Points |
|
A.S. McKendrick |
|
+5T |
-1T |
+12 |
+7 |
+24 |
4 |
+47 |
|
C.I. Morrison |
-5T |
|
+10 |
+17 |
+1T |
+10 |
4 |
+33 |
|
B.R. Durward |
+1T |
-10 |
|
+9T |
-15 |
+16 |
3 |
+1 |
|
F.R. McInnes |
-12 |
-17 |
-9T |
|
+18 |
+12 |
2 |
-8 |
|
J. Walker |
-7 |
-1T |
+15 |
-18 |
|
-6 |
1 |
-17 |
|
F. Mann |
-24 |
-10 |
-16 |
-12 |
+6 |
|
1 |
-56 |
Final: A.S. McKendrick beat C.I. Morrison +26
2001:
|
|
JW |
FRM |
FM |
Wins |
|
Jamieson Walker |
|
-3, +14 |
+8, +13 |
3 |
|
Fergus McInnes |
+3, -14 |
|
+19, +6T |
3 |
|
Fred Mann |
-8, -13 |
-19, -6T |
|
0 |
Final: Jamieson Walker beat Fergus McInnes +2T
2002:
|
|
PM |
DAT |
RP |
JB |
JDS |
JW |
FRM |
Wins |
|
Peter McDermott |
|
+1T |
+6T |
+23 |
+1T |
+23 |
+11 |
6 |
|
David Tester |
-1T |
|
+12 |
+14 |
+12 |
+25 |
+21 |
5 |
|
Rodney Parkins |
-6T |
-12 |
|
+1 |
+6T |
-10 |
+15 |
3 |
|
Jeffery Billing |
-23 |
-14 |
-1 |
|
+13 |
+6 |
-4 |
2 |
|
John Seddon |
-1T |
-12 |
-6T |
-13 |
|
+4T |
+1T |
2 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-23 |
-25 |
+10 |
-6 |
-4T |
|
+4T |
2 |
|
Fergus McInnes |
-11 |
-21 |
-15 |
+4 |
-1T |
-4T |
|
1 |
2003:
|
|
FRM |
JDS |
JW |
AAW |
Wins |
|
Fergus McInnes |
|
+1T, +23 |
+21, +14 |
+12, +14T |
6 |
|
John Seddon |
-1T, -23 |
|
+1T, +5T |
+13, +9T |
4 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-21, -14 |
-1T, -5T |
|
+12T |
1 |
|
Alan Wilson |
-12, -14T |
-13, -9T |
-12T |
|
0 |
2004:
|
|
JDS |
JW |
ACB |
RGL |
Wins |
|
John Seddon |
|
+14 |
+8T |
+9T |
3 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-14 |
|
+8 |
+18 |
2 |
|
Tony Brightman |
-8T |
-8 |
|
+22 |
1 |
|
Robert Lay |
-9T |
-18 |
-22 |
|
0 |
2005:
|
|
JDS |
MAS |
JW |
RAH |
AF |
Wins |
|
John Seddon |
|
-2T |
+12 |
+5 |
+22 |
3 |
|
Martin Stephenson |
+2T |
|
+16 |
-6 |
+9 |
3 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-12 |
-16 |
|
+2 |
+7 |
2 |
|
Allan Hawke |
-5 |
+6 |
-2 |
|
-3T |
1 |
|
Alice Fleck |
-22 |
-9 |
-7 |
+3T |
|
1 |
Final (14-pt advanced): John Seddon beat Martin Stephenson +5T
2006: Block A:
|
|
JRH |
AAW |
RAH |
JW |
Wins |
|
James Hopgood |
|
+2T |
+3T |
+1T |
3 |
|
Alan Wilson |
-2T |
|
+18 |
+4 |
2 |
|
Allan Hawke |
-3T |
-18 |
|
+6 |
1 |
|
Jamieson Walker |
-1T |
-4 |
-6 |
|
0 |
Block B:
|
|
MAS |
JDS |
IHW |
RGL |
Wins |
|
Martin Stephenson |
|
+15 |
+8T |
+6 |
3 |
|
John Seddon |
-15 |
|
+4T |
+23 |
2 |
|
Ian Wright |
-8T |
-4T |
|
+1T |
1 |
|
Robert Lay |
-6 |
-23 |
-1T |
|
0 |
Final: Martin Stephenson beat James Hopgood +21
2007:
|
|
FRM |
RAH |
RMS |
JW |
JDS |
Wins |
|
F.R. McInnes |
|
+21tp |
+13 |
+18 |
+20 |
4 |
|
R.A. Hawke |
-21 |
|
-10 |
+6 |
+24 |
2 |
|
R.M. Stevens |
-13 |
+10 |
|
-9 |
+2T |
2 |
|
J. Walker |
-18 |
-6 |
+9 |
|
-8 |
1 |
|
J.D. Seddon |
-20 |
-24 |
-2T |
+8 |
|
1 |
2008: not contested
2009:
|
|
AAW |
RAH |
ACB |
JDS |
Wins |
|
A.A. Wilson |
|
+4 |
+14, +21 |
+23, +5 |
5 |
|
R.A. Hawke |
-4 |
|
+20, -15 |
+19, +22 |
3 |
|
A.C. Brightman |
-14, -21 |
-20, +15 |
|
+2, -2T |
2 |
|
J.D. Seddon |
-23, -5 |
-19, -22 |
-2, +2T |
|
1 |
2010:
|
|
RAH |
TLW |
JDS |
Wins |
|
R.A. Hawke |
|
-2, +4 |
+2T, +20 |
3 |
|
T.L. Whateley |
+2, -4 |
|
-2T, +10 |
2 |
|
J.D. Seddon |
-2T, -20 |
+2T, -10 |
|
1 |
2011:
|
|
RAH |
RCS |
EM |
Wins |
|
R.A. Hawke |
|
+21, +16 |
+20, +18 |
4 |
|
R.C. Sowerby |
-21, -16 |
|
+12, +4T |
2 |
|
E. Medway |
-20, 18 |
-12, -4T |
|
0 |
2012:
|
|
RAH |
RWI |
HD |
JD |
Wins |
|
R.A. Hawke |
|
+1T |
+8 |
+11 |
3 |
|
R.W. Inder |
-1T |
|
-2T |
+18 |
1 |
|
H. Duguid |
-8 |
+2T |
|
|
1 |
|
J. Duguid |
-11 |
-18 |
|
|
0 |
The match between Hamish Duguid and Janice Duguid was not completed