16-21 August 2004, Fettes College
EVENT 1: Open Singles (Advanced Play) — The Cramond Cup
|
|
AH
|
JB
|
FRM
|
PM
|
GOB
|
Wins
|
Points
|
|
Andrew Hobbs
|
—
|
+10
|
+24TP
|
+18
|
+1
|
4
|
+53
|
|
John Beech
|
-10
|
—
|
+2
|
+7
|
+8t
|
3
|
+7
|
|
Fergus McInnes
|
-24
|
-2
|
—
|
+14
|
+5
|
2
|
-7
|
|
Peter McDermott
|
-18
|
-7
|
-14
|
—
|
+7t
|
1
|
-32
|
|
Graham Brightwell
|
-1
|
-8t
|
-5
|
-7t
|
—
|
0
|
-21
|
EVENT 2: Singles, Advanced Play (handicap 4 and over) — The Ian H. Wright Trophy
|
|
JDS
|
JW
|
ACB
|
RGL
|
Wins
|
Points
|
|
John Seddon
|
—
|
+14
|
+8t
|
+9t
|
3
|
+31
|
|
Jamieson Walker
|
-14
|
—
|
+8
|
+18
|
2
|
+12
|
|
Tony Brightman
|
-8t
|
-8
|
—
|
+22
|
1
|
+6
|
|
Robert Lay
|
-9t
|
-18
|
-22
|
—
|
0
|
-49
|
EVENT 3: Handicap Singles, Advanced Play with Bisques (handicap 8 and over)
— The Silver Jubilee Salver
|
|
RAH
|
MSE
|
MAS
|
RG
|
Wins
|
Points
|
|
Allan Hawke
|
—
|
+10
|
-3t
|
+12
|
2
|
+19
|
|
Mark Elliot
|
-10
|
—
|
+10t
|
+1t
|
2
|
+1
|
|
Martin Stephenson
|
+3t
|
-10t
|
—
|
+4t
|
2
|
-3
|
|
Ruth Goudie
|
-12
|
-1t
|
-4t
|
—
|
0
|
-17
|
Tie-breakers:
Martin Stephenson beat Mark Elliot +11t
Martin Stephenson beat Allan Hawke +3t
EVENT 4: Handicap Singles, Full Bisques relative to a base of 12 (handicap 14 and over) — The Walter B. Laing Cup
Block A:
|
|
JWB
|
RTC
|
KRH
|
PWB
|
Wins
|
Points
|
|
Walter Brown
|
—
|
+5
|
+4t
|
+10t
|
3
|
+19
|
|
Robert Cross
|
-5
|
—
|
+12
|
+12
|
2
|
+19
|
|
Kathy Holland
|
-4t
|
-12
|
—
|
+7t
|
1
|
-9
|
|
Peggy Bartlett
|
-10t
|
-12
|
-7t
|
—
|
0
|
-29
|
Block B:
|
|
GLH
|
JL
|
LH
|
OJC
|
Wins
|
Points
|
|
Graeme Holland
|
—
|
+4t
|
+4t
|
+2t
|
3
|
+10
|
|
Joe Lennon
|
-4t
|
—
|
+14t
|
+14t
|
2
|
+24
|
|
Lindsay Hobbs
|
-4t
|
-14t
|
—
|
+1t
|
1
|
-17
|
|
Joyce Cowie
|
-2t
|
-14t
|
-1t
|
—
|
0
|
-17
|
Final: Graeme Holland beat Walter Brown +7t
EVENT 5: Handicap Doubles (for pairs of combined handicap 5 and over) — The Norton Wright Trophies
Round 1:
Andrew Hobbs & Lindsay Hobbs beat Allan Hawke & Joyce Cowie +3t
Martin Stephenson & Joe Lennon beat Peggy Bartlett & Margaret McBride +20
Rod Williams & Charlotte Townsend beat Graeme Holland & Kathy Holland +1t
Angus Bell & Robert Skeen beat John Beech & Mark Elliot +1t
Quarter-finals:
Fred Mann & Brian Smith beat Fiona Stewart & Jean Forshall +7t
Hobbs & Hobbs beat Stephenson & Lennon +5t
Williams & Townsend beat Bell & Skeen +1t
Malcolm O’Connell & Fergus McInnes beat Marjorie Elliott & Robert Cross +7
Semifinals:
Hobbs & Hobbs beat Mann & Smith +8
O’Connell & McInnes beat Williams & Townsend +16
Final:
Andrew Hobbs & Lindsay Hobbs beat Malcolm O’Connell & Fergus McInnes +22
EVENT 6: Handicap Singles, Unrestricted (X) — The Edinburgh Cup
Round 1:
John Seddon beat Robert Skeen +14
Charlotte Townsend beat Robert Lay +5
Allan Hawke beat Kathy Holland +11t
Round 2:
Fergus McInnes beat Graham Brightwell +14
Graeme Holland beat John Beech +26
Mark Elliot beat Joyce Cowie +5t
John Seddon beat Andrew Hobbs +14
Allan Hawke beat Charlotte Townsend +1t
Rod Williams beat Angus Bell +16
Joe Henderson beat Lindsay Hobbs +2t
Martin Stephenson beat Joe Lennon +4t
Quarter-finals:
Graeme Holland beat Fergus McInnes +26
John Seddon beat Mark Elliot +18
Allan Hawke beat Rod Williams +20
Joe Henderson beat Martin Stephenson +5
Semifinals:
Graeme Holland beat John Seddon +2t
Allan Hawke beat Joe Henderson +1t
Final:
Graeme Holland beat Allan Hawke +13t
EVENT 6: Handicap Singles, Unrestricted (Swiss) — The Milne Trophy
Results in italic are carried over from Event 6X. The players shown in parentheses are the finalists in Event 6X. Each player’s results are not necessarily shown in chronological order, but the wins and the losses in any one column represent the same set of games.
|
(Allan
|
Hawke)
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
(WIN)
|
(WIN)
|
(WIN)
|
—
|
loss
|
|
(7 / 8)
|
|
John
|
Seddon
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
|
|
7 / 8
|
|
(Graeme
|
Holland)
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
—
|
WIN
|
(WIN)
|
—
|
(WIN)
|
(loss)
|
WIN
|
|
(6 / 7)
|
|
John
|
Beech
|
loss
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
loss
|
—
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
7 / 9
|
|
Rod
|
Williams
|
WIN
|
—
|
loss
|
—
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
|
4 / 7
|
|
Joe
|
Lennon
|
loss
|
WIN
|
—
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
5 / 9
|
|
Charlotte
|
Townsend
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2 / 4
|
|
Martin
|
Stephenson
|
WIN
|
loss
|
—
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
|
|
3 / 7
|
|
Graham
|
Brightwell
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
—
|
loss
|
—
|
WIN
|
|
3 / 7
|
|
Andrew
|
Hobbs
|
—
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
|
|
|
|
2 / 5
|
|
Kathy
|
Holland
|
loss
|
—
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
WIN
|
|
|
|
|
2 / 5
|
|
Lindsay
|
Hobbs
|
loss
|
loss
|
—
|
loss
|
WIN
|
—
|
—
|
WIN
|
|
|
2 / 5
|
|
Fergus
|
McInnes
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
—
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
|
3 / 8
|
|
Joe
|
Henderson
|
WIN
|
WIN
|
—
|
loss
|
loss
|
loss
|
loss
|
|
|
|
2 / 6
|
|
Angus
|
Bell
|
loss
|
loss
|
—
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
|
|
|
2 / 6
|
|
Robert
|
Lay
|
loss
|
WIN
|
—
|
—
|
—
|
loss
|
|
|
|
|
1 / 3
|
|
Robert
|
Skeen
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
—
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
|
|
2 / 7
|
|
Mark
|
Elliot
|
WIN
|
—
|
loss
|
loss
|
loss
|
WIN
|
loss
|
loss
|
loss
|
|
2 / 8
|
|
Joyce
|
Cowie
|
loss
|
loss
|
loss
|
—
|
loss
|
loss
|
|
|
|
|
0 / 5
|
Details of Swiss games:
Allan Hawke* beat Angus Bell +17, Joe Lennon +12, Robert Skeen +3t
John Seddon beat John Beech +17, Fergus McInnes +12, Rod Williams +12,
Graham Brightwell +23
Graeme Holland* beat Martin Stephenson +1t, Andrew Hobbs +26
John Beech beat Graham Brightwell +9, Robert Skeen +14, Joe Henderson +11,
Martin Stephenson +7, Andrew Hobbs +5, Rod Williams +16, Joe Lennon +11
Rod Williams beat Martin Stephenson +5, Robert Lay +4, Fergus McInnes +14
Joe Lennon beat Lindsay Hobbs +20, Mark Elliot +9, Joe Henderson +8,
Graeme Holland* +2t, Graham Brightwell +4t
Charlotte Townsend beat Kathy Holland +10t
Martin Stephenson beat Robert Skeen +6t, Angus Bell +17
Graham Brightwell beat Joyce Cowie +6t, Kathy Holland +9t, Mark Elliot +2
Andrew Hobbs beat Fergus McInnes +15, Joe Henderson +19
Kathy Holland beat Lindsay Hobbs +11t, Joyce Cowie +13t
Lindsay Hobbs beat Joyce Cowie +9t, Mark Elliot +7t
Fergus McInnes beat Mark Elliot +15, Joe Lennon +7
Angus Bell beat Charlotte Townsend +23, Mark Elliot +14t
Robert Lay beat Angus Bell +17
Robert Skeen beat Joyce Cowie +14, Fergus McInnes +1t
Mark Elliot beat Robert Skeen +14
(* finalist in Event 6X)
Lauder Bowl (player getting furthest without winning an event): Allan Hawke
10-12 August 2004, St Catharines, Ontario
Canada had held the Maple Shield, the trophy for this biennial match, since its inception, with wins at Bush in 1998 and in Toronto in 2000 followed by a draw at Meadows West in 2002. Scotland had some difficulty in raising a team for the 2004 match, as several players who had initially shown interest turned out not to be available, and we were on the verge of having to cancel when Bill Spalding, who had not played seriously for over 10 years, came to the rescue. "If you were really, really stuck," said his email at the end of February, "there is a possibility that I could be in Canada for the match." The relieved Match Secretary replied "We are really stuck!" - and so it was that a Scottish team, a weaker team than in previous years but nevertheless a team of four, came together at Ridley College in the Southern Ontario town of St Catharines on the evening of Monday 9 August 2004 in readiness for commencing battle against Canada's representatives the following morning.
Read more: Canada v Scotland 2004